UPDATED ON:
Sunday, July 06, 2008
16:12 Mecca time, 13:12 GMT
 
Focus 60 Years of Division
Israel 'committing memorycide'
 By Ilan Pappe

Ilan Pappe says Israel needs to acknowledge the crime it committed
against the Palestinian people

As part of Al Jazeera's coverage of the anniversary of the creation of Israel and the Palestinian 'Nakba', Israeli historian Ilan Pappe reflects upon the events of 1948 and how they led to 60 years of division between the Israelis and Palestinians.

Between February, 1948 and December,1948 the Israeli army systematically occupied the Palestinian villages and towns, expelled by force the population and in most cases also destroyed the houses, looted their belongings and took over their material and cultural possessions. This was the ethnic cleansing of Palestine.

During the ethnic cleansing, wherever there was resistance by the population the result was a massacre. We have more than 30 cases of such massacres where a few thousand Palestinians were massacred by the Israeli forces throughout the operation of the ethnic cleansing.

Pappe says the Israeli army systematically
forced Palestinians from their homes
The Israeli army became a bit tired toward the end of the operation and the Palestinian villages became more aware of what was awaiting them and therefore in the Upper Galilee the Israeli army did not succeed in expelling all of the villages. This is why today we have what we call the Arab-Israelis or Israeli-Arabs.

This is a group of 50 to 60 villages that remained within the state of Israel and its population was steadfast and was not expelled over to the other side of the border - to Lebanon or Syria.

The international community was aware of the ethnic cleansing but the international community, especially in the West, decided not to confront head on the Jewish community in Palestine after the Holocaust.

And, therefore, there was a kind of conspiracy of silence and again the international community did not react and was complacent and this was very important for the Israelis because it showed them that they can adopt as a state ideology ethnic cleansing and ethnic purity.

Erasing history

Part of any ethnic cleansing operation is not just wiping out the population and expelling it from the earth. A very typical part of ethnic cleansing is wiping people out of history.

For ethnic cleansing to be an effective and successful operation you also have to wipe people out of memory and the Israelis are very good at it. They did it in two ways.

They built Jewish settlements over the Palestinian villages they expelled and quite often gave them names that reflected the Palestinian name as a kind of testimony to the Palestinians that this is totally now in the hands of Israel and there is no chance in the world of bringing the clock backwards.

Pappe says many former Palestinian villages
were turned into recreational spaces
The other way they did it is planting trees - usually European pine trees - over the ruins of the village and turning the village into recreational spaces where you do exactly the opposite of commemoration - you live the day, you enjoy life, it is all about leisure and pleasure.

That is a very powerful tool for 'memorycide'. In fact, much of the Palestinian effort should have been but was never unfortunately - or only recently began - was to fight against that 'memorycide' by at least bringing back the memory of what happened.

I think that there should be no reason in the world that two people - the Palestinians and the Jews - despite everything that happened in the past should not be able live together effective and in one state.

You need three things for that to happen. You need closure for the 1948 story - namely you need an Israeli acknowledgment of the crime it committed against the Palestinian people.

The second thing that you need is you need to make Israel accountable for this and the only way of making Israel accountable is by, at least in principle, accepting the Palestinian refugees right of return.

And thirdly you need a change in the Palestinian and Arab position towards the idea of a Jewish presence in Palestine as something legitimate and natural and not as an alien colonialist force.

I think these principles have to emerge and so far the political elites on both sides are unwilling to accept them.

The views expressed by the author are not necessarily those of Al Jazeera.

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 16
 
v
United States
23/06/2008
How does Israel have a legitimate claim to that land now? If they have one, who has the legitimate claim to much of the land that was historically occupied by those different than who it occupy now.

john
Australia
23/06/2008
memorycide
its interesting that we never hear from any arab and or iranian or pakistani historians about the right of return of the milions of jews who were driven out of their homes in middle east and north africa.

art alvitre, native american of so. california
United States
23/06/2008
american memorycide
adolph hitler praised the united states on their methods of destroying the american indian by mass genocide, and making them the terrorist of the time.

Thad
United States
24/06/2008
committing memorycide
A continuation of the Arab revisionist history.

kj
Afghanistan
24/06/2008
jews are trying to exploit
60 year lifespan of the palestinian dispora. when they kill children, teenagers and hope the elderly die of age, then they have less "skeletons in the closet" for reparations.

Morgan Gibson
Australia
26/06/2008
Bi-nationalism
This is one of the few times I have seen the prospect of a bi-national solution to the Israeli-Palestine conflict. While I think more needs to be done than is mentioned, this is a wonderful thing to see!

olegxander
United States
26/06/2008
Complete Crap!
zero truth to any of this. Zero mention that Arab armies were the ones that forced palestinians off their own land. 1000's arabs died because they wanted war but couldnt fight. How many jews were killed by arabs?

Robert
Afghanistan
29/06/2008
Memorycide
I suppose both Israel and Palestine are guilty of memorycide. Who was the promised son, Isaac or Ishmael? Answer that question correctly and you will soon start digging to reveal a temple which is currently denied to exist.

John Parker
United States
03/07/2008
An excellent, balanced precis of the historical facts and concluding 3 points are common sense, which unfortunately is not so common these days. Well done Ilan

able_tuno
United States
04/07/2008
60+ years
can I bulldoze some jewish homes in chicago, they are on what god gave the Indians.

dave frasier
United States
04/07/2008
ethnic cleansing continues
The USA should not support ethnic cleansing. The USA should not support the ethnic cleansing of Palestine. Therefore: The USA should not support Israel.

eddie crook
Israel
07/07/2008
palestine/israel
I honestly believe that the only way that lasting peace can be achieved will be by mutual forgiveness for the past and the integration of Jews and Arabs into a single state in which all can grow and prosper for the benefit of future generations.

Anne
United States
08/07/2008
I had a professor repeat, "Visit Israel before it visits you." Myself, I am tired of my tax dollar propping up the Israeli economy and fueling its war machine. Enough!

dan
United States
18/07/2008
simon wiesenthal
the way the jews "got on" (not over) ww2 and the ethnic cleansing was by apprehending the (by then elderly) monsters responsible. i believe the organization that the world funds to investigate and prosecute these is the simon wiesenthal foundation. now, wouldn't it be a REAL good faith gesture for this org to prosecute zionists like nazis? i mean, guilty is guilty... right?

s hasan
Bangladesh
08/07/2008
'committing memorycide' nice story, but ultimete efort to recognise Israel to exist in occupied land of Palestinies.

A different professor
United States
08/07/2008
Visit Israel before it visits you
I find it disheartening that most US professors are so opinionated in their classrooms against Israel, yet so few of them know the history of the Israeli-Arab conflict.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article